A Call for the Proposed Smoking Ban at Atlanta Parks to be Reconsidered
The Southeast Regional Director of the Citizens Freedom Alliance lists compelling evidence for why smoking bans often do not work.
Editor's note: Jeremy Richards, Ph.D., Southeast Regional Director and Director of Historical Research of the Citizens Freedom Alliance, recently sent an email to Atlanta politicians and Buckhead Patch, outlining the reasons he feels smoking bans don't work. Richards, who is a non-smoker, got involved in the struggle against smoking bans after Georgia passed its statewide ban in 2005.
In the email, Richards lists a number of links to articles about failed smoking bans all over the world. The list, which is much too extensive to list in full here, includes the links to failed bans in North America and a few health related studies.
Read on to see what Richards had to say:
Elected officials of ATL,
I recently read on the Internet that the issue of an outdoors smoking ban had been raised in the city. I would strongly urge caution on this issue.
It is true that even these outdoor Mayor Bloomberg-esque bans have had some popularity recently. However, in my research on tobacco prohibitions I have discovered that many of the smoking bans (both outdoor and even some indoor) have begun to fail.
Last week Norcross city council repealed an outdoor city ban. Also, within the last year and a half a smoking ban was repealed in Campbell County, KY, and bans have been scaled back in York County, SC, Galveston, TX, the ENTIRE state of NV, and the nation of the Netherlands, not to mention numerous other indoor and outdoor smoking bans that are just outright ignored (including the park ban in NYC).
This is one issue that the ATL city council needs to avoid. I believe the police have much more important issues to deal with.
Note my growing list of failed/failing smoking bans below.
Failed Norcross parks ban (ban repealed)
Failed Campbell County, KY ban (ban repealed)
Failed York County, SC ban (ban partially scaled back)
Failed Galveston, TX ban (Galveston partially backtracks)
Failed Nevada state ban (big scaleback)
Failed Atlantic City ban (Partial scaleback for casinos)
Hawaii ban (legislator wants to allow smoking permits)
Failing MN ban (legislators want scaleback)
Failing Kansas ban (bill seeks bar exemption)
Failing MI ban (four of five bars ignored)
Failing Wisconsin ban (cops waste money and time enforcing)
Failing American bans (Bars and clubs all over the country)
Failing North Carolina ban (merely five months later)
Studies showing smoking bans are NOT helping anyone healthwise: