.
Feedback

Davis Shows Irritation at APS Redistricting Responses

Superintendent tosses barbs at Buckhead neighborhoods

APS Superintendent Erroll B. Davis Jr. in an interview session with Patch editors Monday expressed irritation at Buckhead responses over the APS redistricting process.

Pointing out "I am not an elected official," he singled out the community for the volume of e-mails he's received, with the same message, "keep Brandon Brandon." He said that when receiving 100 such form responses, he considers just one of them and doesn't read the rest.

He also showed a mix of amusement and distaste at what he said was the demanding tone of comments from across the city, particularly Virginia-Highland and Buckhead. "They snatch defeat from the jaws of victory," he said.

In response to Buckhead concerns that moving Centennial Place Elementary students would disrupt the community's k-12 international baccalaureate framework, Davis said, "I am not persuaded by the IB argument." He said APS has several rigorous programs, including the AP curriculum. "IB is just one path; it is not a panacea," he said.

He said that , for years the only school in the Southeast with an IB program, "is not even the best performing high school in the system." He said that distinction belongs to Carver Arts School.

The new North Atlanta High is costing $70 million to build, he said, "quite a bit to spend" when the APS capital budget is $100 million.

Although not specificially referencing proposals to send Centennial Place students to Buckhead middle schools and high schools, he said, "I raise my eyebrows a bit when I hear comments about 'those children,' and not 'their children.' That causes some concern." Buckhead parents have uniformly opposed the option to move Centennial Place students from School Reform Team 3 to SRT 4, which includes Buckhead.

Also, he also suggested that the proposal to rebuild is not a certainty. He said he would consider redoing the school to a capacity of 750 students, but a place must be found to send students during the construction work, which could last one and a half to two years. "We're not going to place tents on the front lawn," he said.

"Build a school at E. Rivers: We will find it if it is in fact doable," he said.

He also said "middle schools are the real issue" in the redistricting debate, as reported on Virginia-Highland Patch. Davis praised the Old Fourth Ward neighborhood for the measured tone of its responses, as noted in this article on East Atlanta Patch.

Jimmy Schulte February 14, 2012 at 06:36 pm
When is Buckhead going to secede from Atlanta?
Serge A Storms February 14, 2012 at 09:09 pm
Why oh why is the APS such a joke? Let's see... Davis?
Sam Brown February 14, 2012 at 11:41 pm
Tomorrow would not be soon enough. Where do I sign up?
Helen February 15, 2012 at 03:31 pm
Davis needs some PR Coaching...bad. He has insulted so many constituents and districts in Atlanta in this one video alone. The take away from this video that Mr. Davis provides to anyone listening is that Mr. Davis is: a.) emotionally involved and not reviewing facts b.) actions are motivated by emotion (revenge) and not realistic data and c.) highly unqualified for the position he holds.
Shame on Atlanta!
AHW February 15, 2012 at 06:23 pm
The Davis interview is very disappointing. Our community has worked tirelessly over the past decade to get our cluster of schools to where they are today. The behavior of Davis in this interview is disturbing and offensive quite frankly. Don't fault the Brandon community for caring about our schools and for caring about the education of our children. We are only advocating for our children -- WE CARE! Any inappropriate comments made by a FEW of the Brandon parents does not reflect how most of us feel. Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't you have to apply to Carver Arts School and hope to be admitted? It is not a true Public School like North Atlanta so don't compare apples to oranges! Regarding middle schools and concerns over sports, 6th grade is intramurals only anyway and for 7th and 8th you could have 7th grade teams and 8th grade teams -- concern solved. At Sutton Middle School, the sports programs are funded mostly, if not entirely, by the PTA! It's imperative to maintain our STRONG PTA not only for sports, but for several other educational and cultural programs we would not have otherwise.
tn February 16, 2012 at 02:31 am
Very offensive. He seems to have a lot of hostility towards the Buckhead parents who do not want to maintain a country club but rather have passion towards the schools they helped succeed over many years. E Rivers is a diverse, wonderful school that succeeds because of the teachers AND community that has invested in it. 60% minority - and we want to KEEP it that way. Davis, you are a shame to APS and Atlanta. Perhaps you should focus on addressing the cheating scandal and other schools that are not succeeding and leave the successful ones alone.
northside mom February 16, 2012 at 01:26 pm
How many country clubs have a food bank for their own members?? Davis is obviously out of touch with who we(Brandon) really are!
Frank DiGeorge February 16, 2012 at 01:58 pm
Some more facts about IB the district won't tell you:
1) Compared to AP, IB will increase college costs for most students. 2) The IB diploma required TOK class is composed entirely of questions like, "When can it be right to disobey the law? Can suicide bombers be right?" 3) IB will not improve student performance. 4) IB's pedagogical method is one of constructivism and inquiry based learning to promote a specific ideology. 5) IB is extremely expensive. 6) Many schools drop IB, learn why at article below. 7) Some people have religious concerns with IB. 8) IB is an NGO of UNESCO (UN) and the goal is to promote the UN ideology. 9) At the elementary level IB is forced on all children in the school and the stated goal is to "develop attitudes," and to get students to "take action." 10) With IB, schools give up some local control to a Swiss organization. 11) AP is the best fit for gifted students. 12) When IB/AP classes are combined the IB material must take priority. 13) For the IB diploma students must complete 10 required classes in 11th and 12th grade. 14) IB is implemented in a deceitful way over and over throughout the United States. Once someone questions IB an open and honest discussion is never allowed, and the community becomes divided. To find proof supporting all the points above read the entire article. http://myinclinevillage.com/2011/07/31/what-all-parents--students-should-know-before-enrolling-in-ib.aspx
JH February 16, 2012 at 02:36 pm
This is a truly astounding interview. Where in the world did the "country club" comment come from? I live in Buckhead and don't belong to a country club. This guy is a racist and his hatred seethes from him. His arrogance is disturbing and is clear that he cares NOTHING about the children whose education is in his charge and this is about a broader personal agenda he has. He is the Peter Principle in action.
William February 16, 2012 at 04:31 pm
Wow! I sure hope Mr. Davis realizes that you all are only a "part" of Buckhead. Don't lump us all into your small group. He is doing a great job despite your whining and antics. You're just upset because he sees through it.
VR February 16, 2012 at 08:26 pm
I worked for Errol Davis when he was President and CEO of Alliant Energy from which he retired from. He made extraordinarily balanced and fair decisions, decisions on transmission lines and power plants that would impact hundreds of thousands of people in Iowa and Wisconsin. He grew the company while keeping it out of the Enron tornado that sucked so many companies like Alliant into the drain. He sits on the Board of Directors of General Motors and Union Pacific and was on the board of BP, plc. The man did not take this job for the money folks. I could not think of anyone who could potentially be a better candidate to salvage the Atlanta School system.
Calling him a racist just reflects ignorance on the part of the writer. PS--I live in Morris Brandon district and have seen the unnecessary hysteria first hand.
WT February 16, 2012 at 08:45 pm
VR- your comments are interesting. Can one put the "country club" comment in any other category but that of race?. Will you, in your enlightened view, explain what Mr. Davis really meant by his unfortunate choice of words? It is very surprising to hear such a vitriolic tone from someone with such a remarkable pedigree. But I guess Kings will be Kings. I'm sure that you can agree, can't you, that Mr. Davis in this interview is emotional, arrogant, and unprofessional. That kind of talk probably wouldn't get him very far at a GM board meeting. It seems bush league to alienate the very people who have worked so hard to help APS achieve a modicum of success at some of its schools.
Rick Volkmann February 16, 2012 at 09:02 pm
We in SRT4 have been passionate supporters of our schools, and it shows through the participation in the PTA, which funds many programs (technology, foreign language, staff) that are simply critical. Our schools represent a diverse and rich student population. With private schools surrounding us here, we make the extra effort to participate in our kids' success at public school.
Why Superintendent Davis is driving a disruptive re-organization of the school boundaries? It's such a setback to a set of schools that are thriving through tremendous community support. I've heard modest support at best for the proposed changes and a deafening chorus against it. Who benefits from this? Can anyone answer that? Mr. Davis surely hasn't.
LJ February 17, 2012 at 12:52 am
Also, Mr. Davis stresses that redistricting is necessary to achieve cost savings in the district. I have not seen any numbers indicating that these proposals will in fact save money. These proposals call for the building of new schools instead of expanding existing ones. The cost of the real estate alone seem to render these options more expensive. Why not focus on removing the 100 plus teachers that were fired in the cheating probe that is currently costing the district in excess of $1 million per month?
Kylie February 17, 2012 at 09:37 pm
Racist? Seriously? Communities need to understand that the way our country has chosen to allocate money to schools via property tax greatly effects the education of children who don't live in those neighborhoods. Stop being so selfish! APS "wealthy" parents are as territorial as drug king pins! Ridiculous!
LLM February 19, 2012 at 05:17 am
If Mr. Davis was listening, he'd hear that parents across this city all want the same thing. We all want our children to attend a neighborhood community school that gives our children the education they deserve. Instead of shuffling kids around or closing underperforming schools, make the appropriate changes and investments to improve our schools. Buckhead parents don't want their kids moved, but parents at Centenniel and other schools don't want their kids moved either!
LLM February 19, 2012 at 05:23 am
His comment of "I'm not an elected official" is pretty telling... I wish he was - he certainly would not be getting my vote.
Katie February 19, 2012 at 05:20 pm
The funding for building schools comes from E-SPLOST funds, and not the regular APS budget. E-SPLOST money cannot be used for day to day school operations (paying teacher salaries as one example). Unfortunately, because of this, simply opting to not build new schools can't be part of the argument against redistricting. The money is allocated for them already and can be used for nothing else.
AHW February 20, 2012 at 07:14 pm
we are not "wealthy" which is why we send our kids to public school
jane smith February 22, 2012 at 02:27 pm
Why not an outside audit to see if APS could save money by cleaning out the central office? Check out this article comparing the numbers of bureaucrats in Fulton vs. Cobb public schools.
http://blogs.ajc.com/get-schooled-blog/2012/01/18/outside-audit-of-dekalb-school-system-slash-the-central-office-by-more-than-300-jobs/ I would LOVE to see the ratio of administrators to students in Atlanta Public Schools. This year we will pay $25K in property tax (E Rivers district) and send our daughter to private school. We just cannot turn her over to a system led by those with such open hostility toward our (or any) neighborhood. Brandon parents belong in the "Spam Filter" and E Rivers parents don't deserve to know his plans as he has already decided we won't like any of them. We are currently shopping for a home in Cobb County. Watch tax revenues drop with home values as those paying into the system vote the only way they can--with their feet. Put that in your Spam Filter, Mr. Davis.
Me February 23, 2012 at 01:08 pm
Jane Smith, you hit the nail on the head! We're in Sarah Smith, but send our kids private. With home prices tanking, why do we continue to pay such high property taxes? We, too, are entertaining the idea of crossing the border to Cobb county with our tax dollars. I'm so tired of the mismanagement of our tax dollars. There was no way I'd let them mismanage our children's education, so why do I let them continue to mismanage my tax dollars? You're so right, vote with your feet! Plenty of nice homes for sale right on the other side of the 'hooch and you can easily drop about $10,000 off your property taxes without batting an eye! Mr. Davis needs to stop bashing Buckhead parents and instead thank us for our tax dollars.
John Riley February 28, 2012 at 01:46 am
I'm in IB, and Iove it.
It's a wonderful program which fosters a type of thinking a couple of steps above AP. I think that you should reconsider your position based upon input from students.
John Riley February 28, 2012 at 01:50 am
What school do your kids go to?
p fajinmi March 8, 2012 at 06:57 am
i am a parent of a student at centennial i currently live at atlantic station...we love the school however i notice most of the over crowding of both e rivers and centennial stem from aps school teachers sending their kids to those schools i see so many out of county cars dropping off...centennial is a year round school whose students who are in the district are mostly ga state and ga tech parents....our schools nor the lines need to be changed nor the cluster...if a kid misses a school bus do aps know how much it cost and how long it take for public transportan? centennial should be inman and grady...just as erivers should be sutton and north atlanta......the real question is why are they moving our good students to bad school areas with cheating and failing grades is it to boast the scores of the under acheiving schools because they cant move great performing teachers because of the unions?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Buckhead Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something